Do you *have* to have it, no...Is it a very wise decision to have one YES!!! If I had one I wouldn't be on the blown list. It senses knock and detonation and automatically retards timing or shuts the car down if it senses detonation, that way it shuts the car down or puts it in limp mode be fore something very bad happens.
your wideband wont protect against detonation.....
ive been reading up on it and a J&S will most likely save the motor in case of detonation occurs even if your car is tuned....
on that note youre gonna need both anyway
__________________
-Anthony- PSN/Xbox Live GT: Evoking1230
2005 EVO VIII-SOLD/R.I.P.
2000 Honda Prelude SH - Gone But Not Forgotten
well if your car is tuned and your not runnin cheap ass gas on obsurd amounts of boost you shouldn't detenate. What the main cause of detenating?? Running lean. The wideband will tell you if your running lean. It will show you your runnin lean before u start to detenate where as the j&s adjust after u start to detenate.
__________________
The DARKSIDE awaits you!!
360 whp
409.9 ft-lbs of torque
gotta love a turbo h23...
Detonation is caused by the remaining air/fuel mixture exploding at once which puts a lot of pressure on the pistons, etc... So to control this from happening you can retard the spark. J&S will do this. So I would recommend getting not only a wideband which is great for tuning but also a J&S to stop detonation.
__________________
Joe
2007 Brilliant Red Audi A4 2.0T Quattro S Line - Leased
Originally posted by myleftlung not to flame or be an ass but if you searched you would of got all ur answers
dont you know post whores always search before posting???
and besides....looking at all the research ive collected and other peoples setups i really didnt see a J&S on anyones list so i was confused about to get it or not
__________________
-Anthony- PSN/Xbox Live GT: Evoking1230
2005 EVO VIII-SOLD/R.I.P.
2000 Honda Prelude SH - Gone But Not Forgotten
well when i see anyone that has over 350whp and still use it maybe i'll think about it. It seems that the only people i see using it are the people boosting less then 12-14lbs on stock motors.
__________________
The DARKSIDE awaits you!!
360 whp
409.9 ft-lbs of torque
gotta love a turbo h23...
That doesn't mean it is right. Do a search and I am sure you will find that a lot of people recommend it. Call up soem good shops and they will tell you to use it. And say people don't tell youto use it, why not spend a few hundred on a system that will prevent detonation.
__________________
Joe
2007 Brilliant Red Audi A4 2.0T Quattro S Line - Leased
AutoForums.com is the premier network of enthusiast-owned
enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
We operate more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share
experiences and opinions as a community.